News channel's future must be secred even with Disney waiting in the wings
Rupert Murdoch's 21st Century Fox is back with some fresh proposals in an attempt to find a way through the regulatory logjam that has stymied its long held ambition to acquire the part of broadcaster Sky that it doesn’t own.
Touted as further strengthening the editorial independence of Sky News, the loss making channel that represents a tiny part of the overall business but has left the deal stuck in the mud, they were accepted by Sky this morning. The plan would be for its news channel to be set up as a legally separate entity within the group with a five to seven strong board of directors, chaired by an “independent expert” with experience of journalism. Three Sky independent directors would also serve.
Clever, because the set up looks quite similar to the deal communications watchdog OfCom agreed that allowed BT to keep hold of its broadband infrastructure arm OpenReach in the face of demands by rivals for it to be spun off (including, it should be noted, Sky).
- Sky News could be sold to Disney early in bid to push through Sky sale
- Sky Sports axe long-serving presenter Sawyer after 18 years
- Sky reveals gender pay gap of 11.5% and bonus gap of 40%
An earlier offer was rejected by the Competition & Markets Authority (CMA) which said it was minded to block the deal because of the Murdoch family’s effective control nearly of a third of Britain’s “national voice” (TV, radio, newspapers, websites). But what's good for the goose…
A further twist is that Sky News could be sold to Disney immediately after the “separation” is complete regardless of whether Disney gets the approvals it is attempting to secure so it can buy the lion’s share of Fox (including Sky).
There are those who would argue that the latter deal makes all this an irrelevance. Disney, after all, doesn’t pose the same sort “voice” issues that the Murdochs do, something that the CMA has acknowledged.
But the Disney deal has regulatory issues of its own, particularly across the Atlantic, so it might’t happen. It gets still more complicated when you consider the stated interest of US cable TV giant Comcast in bidding for Sky.
All of this explains why the status of Sky News, an important competitor to the BBC in the provision of 24 hour news, needs to be settled.
Investors in the UK appear minded to let go of a first rate company. It would be a tragedy were a first rate new outlet to be a casualty of that.
But does the "legal separation" of Sky News protect it? That is an open question given who controls the directors' appointment.
Business news: in pictures
Business news: in pictures
Amazon's new Seattle headquarters mimics a greenhouse, with 40,000 different plants aimed at boosting workers productivity
Trinity Mirror, which owns the Daily Mirror, is set to incorporate the parent company of the Daily Express, Sunday Express and the Daily Star. Trinity Mirror stated on Friday that it was buying all of Richard Desmond‘s Northern & Shell’s publishing assets for £126.7m.
Kylie Jenner tweet about snapchat wiped $1.3bn off the stock market value of Snap on Thursday
RBS recorded its first profit since the 2008 financial crash – some way since Fred Goodwin (pictured) felt the heat in the aftermath of the bank's bailout
Samsung heir Jay Y Lee was freed from jail on Monday. He was convicted for corruption and embezzlement with South Korea's former president in 2017.
The total number of electric buses in service is forecast to more than triple, from 386,000 last year to about 1.2 million in 2025, equal to about 47 per cent of the worldwide city bus fleet, according to a report from Bloomberg New Energy Finance
Aldi has removed thousands of kilos of vegetables after a customer complained that she had found part of a rat in one bag of frozen mixed greens. It came after Aldi customer Pat Batemen complained to the budget supermarket chain and was offered £30 compensation, a figure she said was later increased to £500.
Coronation Street is set to get its own Co-op supermarket and Costa Coffee branch in a landmark deal that will see shop fronts appearing on a show as product placements. Viewers of the ITV soap will see both stores open on the street this spring. Co-op's and Costa Coffee's facades will be seen on the show, alongside branded posters, bags and cups used by Coronation Street characters.
John Lewis, M&S, Next, Debenhams and Sainsbury’s are all yet to add their names to a list of brands binding themselves to Bangladesh’s latest laws on fire and building safety. The renewed agreement will see greater investment in health and safety checks come into effect this year as the original 2013 agreement is due to expire in May.
When it comes to the latter Mr Murdoch has always got what Mr Murdoch has wanted. For example, when it was decided that James Murdoch, the current CEO of Fox, should become Sky’s chairman he was duly installed at the head of the board.
As for flipping Sky over to Disney, a rather important question is what happens if Disney doesn’t complete its deal to buy Fox?
It all puts CMA on the spot, and that isn’t a place UK watchdogs tend to find comfortable when it comes to takeovers and mergers, particularly when they involve questions of the national interest.